Acupuncture vs Dry Needling: Which Should You Choose? (Montréal)

Book an appointment at the clinic (opens in a new tab)

The difference in one sentence

Dry needling is a targeted technique that releases painful muscle knots. Acupuncture is a complete approach, regulated by the Ordre des acupuncteurs du Québec (OAQ): people consult for muscular pain as much as for sleep or headaches. These are reasons for consulting, not promises of results.

What is acupuncture?

Acupuncture involves inserting fine needles at precise points on the body to stimulate the nervous system. This stimulation is associated with several studied responses: the release of endorphins (the body’s natural painkillers), pain modulation at the level of the spinal cord, an effect on local inflammation, and activation of the parasympathetic nervous system, the one that calms heart rate and stress.

It’s a millennia-old practice rooted in Traditional Chinese Medicine, whose mechanisms are now studied in Western medicine. The strongest evidence concerns chronic pain: a large individual-patient-data meta-analysis (Vickers et al., 2018; 39 trials, 20,827 patients) concludes acupuncture has a real but modest effect: about 0.2 standard deviations better than sham, and about 0.5 against no treatment, persisting at one year. For other indications, the quality of the data varies.

In Québec, acupuncture is a regulated profession. Only members of the Ordre des acupuncteurs du Québec may use the title of acupuncturist and provide a complete treatment.

What is dry needling?

Dry needling (sometimes called “intramuscular stimulation”) is a more recent technique, developed in the 1980s by Western physicians and physiotherapists. It involves inserting a needle directly into a trigger point: a palpable knot in a muscle that produces local or referred pain.

The aim is mechanical and neurophysiological: to provoke a release response in the muscle, improve local circulation and desensitize the painful area. A systematic review of 13 randomized trials (Gattie et al., J Orthop Sports Phys Ther, 2017; PMID 28158962) reports a short-term reduction in pain (up to twelve weeks) compared with sham needling or no treatment; the authors themselves rate that evidence very low to moderate quality, drawn from small and heterogeneous trials, and the benefit at six to twelve months is no longer statistically significant. In clinic, relief is often felt quickly, sometimes from the first session, especially for acute pain such as low-back pain, neck pain, a frozen shoulder, muscular sciatica or a tendinopathy.

In Québec, dry needling can be performed by physiotherapists holding the required attestation, as well as by acupuncturists who have completed specific training: two distinct scopes of practice, set out below. At the clinic, dry needling is performed by Justin Lapointe, acupuncturist, trained in Whitfield Reaves’ orthopedic approach, within the practice of acupuncture, which includes this kind of targeted needling.

Ashi points: a family resemblance

One nuance is worth flagging, and it nicely complicates the contrast. Dry needling believes it targets something thoroughly modern: the trigger point, that painful muscle knot. Yet Chinese medicine has long had its own “pain points”: the Ashi points. The name is delightful: “Ashi” (阿是穴) is said to come from the patient’s exclamation when the practitioner presses the right spot. “Ah, that’s it.” These are points with no fixed location, found not from a chart but by the pressure that wakes the pain. The resemblance to the trigger point is striking.

It isn’t that one “copied” the other: it’s that two traditions, centuries apart, ran into the same fact of the body — that a knotted muscle calls the needle to the very place where it hurts. The border between the two practices is thus more porous than is often said. Where they truly differ is in what comes after the painful point: dry needling stops there; acupuncture connects it to a whole network.

At a glance

Origin. Acupuncture: Chinese medicine (about two thousand years of textual attestation). Dry needling: Western medicine (40 years).
Target. Acupuncture: points linked to the nervous system. Dry needling: muscular trigger points.
Approach. Acupuncture: holistic (pain, sleep, stress, digestion…). Dry needling: targeted (musculoskeletal pain).
Typical sensation. Acupuncture: tingling, warmth, heaviness. Dry needling: a brief muscle contraction (the “twitch”).
Who may practise in Québec. Acupuncture: acupuncturist (OAQ). Dry needling: physiotherapist holding the PPAS attestation, or trained acupuncturist.
Insurance. Both are often recognized under private plans, and accident-related care may be covered through the SAAQ and CNESST (physiotherapy includes dry needling); a check with your insurer confirms yours.

Which treatment for your situation?

You have localized muscular pain

If you’ve pinpointed a precise spot that hurts (a knot in the trapezius after hours at the computer, calf pain after a run, a stiff shoulder since a move), dry needling often offers quick relief. It’s also an effective option alongside a course of physiotherapy.

You have chronic pain or a broader imbalance

If the pain comes with fatigue, sleep trouble, chronic stress or digestive trouble, acupuncture is the more likely fit: it looks not only at the painful area but at the terrain that keeps it going, working to regulate the nervous system as a whole.

You’re still unsure

An initial consultation lets us assess your situation and choose the right approach. In many cases, the two techniques can be combined within a single treatment plan.

Who can practise these techniques in Québec?

Acupuncture is governed by the Ordre des acupuncteurs du Québec (OAQ). The training that leads there is a three-year technical college diploma (DEC) at Cégep de Rosemont (2,200 hours of training, 1,980 of them specific to acupuncture), followed by admission to the Ordre.

In Québec, dry needling performed by physiotherapists has a framework of its own. The official texts speak of needles « sous le derme », under the dermis; the Ordre professionnel de la physiothérapie du Québec uses the term puncture physiothérapique avec aiguilles sèches (PPAS). The activity is reserved by the Code des professions (RLRQ, chapter C-26, section 37.1, paragraph 3, subparagraph h) and governed by the Règlement sur une activité de formation des physiothérapeutes pour l’utilisation des aiguilles sous le derme (RLRQ, chapter C-26, r. 192): the physiotherapist must hold an attestation issued by their order after at least 102 hours of training; the needling is added to other means within a physiotherapy treatment plan, it does not stand as a treatment on its own; and it excludes any recourse to the principles of traditional Chinese medicine. That is exactly where the border runs: the same act of needling, two distinct scopes of practice.

In all cases, the use of needles is reserved for recognized health professionals: that’s your best protection for safety.

At Mon Acupuncteur, in the Plateau-Mont-Royal, our team combines both skills under one roof: acupuncture and dry needling (Justin), acupuncture (Jessica) and physiotherapy (Josh, a physiotherapist trained at McGill). Our treatments are often recognized by private insurers, and accident-related care may be covered through the SAAQ and CNESST; coverage varies by plan, so a quick check with your insurer confirms yours. Receipts are issued on site.

Frequently asked questions

Does it hurt?

The needles used are far finer than a blood-test needle. Most patients feel a slight prick, followed by a sensation of heaviness or release. Dry needling can produce a brief muscle contraction, sometimes uncomfortable, but short.

How many sessions are needed?

For localized muscular pain treated with dry needling, progress is judged after a few closely spaced sessions. For a broader condition treated with acupuncture, the pace is tighter at first, then spaced out. The number is set with your acupuncturist, with no commitment to a fixed figure. A first session lasts 75 to 90 minutes; follow-ups, 60 to 70 minutes, depending on the practitioner (see our rates).

Does my insurance cover both?

Many private plans recognize acupuncture and physiotherapy separately; coverage varies by contract, so check with your insurer. As part of rehabilitation, the SAAQ and CNESST may cover both, depending on your file’s eligibility. Our receipts are issued on site.

Can I combine the two in the same week?

Yes. It’s even an effective combination for sports conditions or persistent pain: for example, dry needling to release the muscular area, followed by an acupuncture session to calm the nervous system and improve recovery.

Sources

To go further: see our treatments at the clinic.

Book your consultation online → monacupuncteur.janeapp.com

In the Plateau-Mont-Royal, open 7 days a week. OAQ member · OPPQ member. Receipts issued on site.

In the Plateau-Mont-Royal, open 7 days a week. Acupuncturists · OAQ members, physiotherapist · OPPQ member. Insurance receipts issued on site.Our content follows a published editorial methodology.